You Cant Legislate Morality
You cant legislate morality. Laws can only define the limits of acceptable behavior and punishments for those who do not respect these limits. Punishments are always after the fact however and they are only applied to those who are caught and convicted. The truth however is that every law and regulation that is proposed passed and enforced has inherent in it some idea of the good that it seeks to promote or preserve.
The job must be done through education and religion. It is an oft-repeated mantra intended to end all further discussion of an issue robotically reiterated by politicians and pundits from. Indeed no governing authority can in any way be understood to be morally neutral.
All laws make moral claims. The truth is all laws legislate morality even speed limits imply a moral right to life. Civil laws are only a partial curb to the destructive process of sin.
So the real question is not whether morality is legislated but whose morality is legislated. You cant legislate morality This simple phrase holds an honored place among the current wisdom of today. Punishments are always after the fact however and they are only applied to those who are caught and convicted.
Nov 15th 2021 1017 am. Well theres half-truth involved here. You cant legislate morality has become a common turn of phrase.
And ironically this is the one sense in which its true that you cant legislate morality. When it is said in these United States that you cant legislate morality what is usually meant is that the one making the statement does not want Christian morality reflected in the law. You cant legislate morality YOU CANT LEGISLATE MORALITY 1st Timothy 19 Knowing this that the law is not made for a righteous man but for the lawless and disobedient for the ungodly and for sinners for unholy and profane for murderers of fathers and murderers of.
Even something as simple as a traffic law makes a judgement on which behaviors are correct. Make no mistake someones morality will guide our legislation.
Civil laws are only a partial curb to the destructive process of sin.
Make no mistake someones morality will guide our legislation. It is an oft-repeated mantra intended to end all further discussion of an issue robotically reiterated by politicians and pundits from. To legislate against the moral codes of ones fellows is a very grave act requiring for its justification the most indubitable and universally admitted of social gains for it is to steal their moral codes to suppress their characters. Morality Is The Only Thing You CAN Legislate. The answer is obvious. Our laws are all moral laws representing a system of morality. You cant legislate morality Of all the inane witless and tedious clichés that pepper our modern political dialogue perhaps this one annoys me the most although that whole right side of history thing really frosts my rhubarb too. Morality cannot be legislated but behavior can be regulated. Laws can only define the limits of acceptable behavior and punishments for those who do not respect these limits.
All legislation is the legislation of morality - be that morality rooted in the Judeo-Christian ethic or some nebulous secular worldview. Indeed no governing authority can in any way be understood to be morally neutral. As Greg Koukl and Francis Beckwith point out in their excellent book on relativism morality is the only thing you CAN legislate. Morality Is The Only Thing You CAN Legislate. When the humanist tells us therefore that You cant legislate morality what he actually means is that we must not legislate Biblical morality because he means to have humanistic morality legislated. To say you cant legislate morality isnt really sensible if a person means that laws cant be moral or that people shouldnt be under laws they dont personally agree with. Laws can only define the limits of acceptable behavior and punishments for those who do not respect these limits.
Post a Comment for "You Cant Legislate Morality"